Review & Rebuttal Reports
Objective Analysis of the Other Side’s Numbers
When an opposing expert discloses a valuation or damages report, the burden shifts to your side to evaluate it critically and respond. We provide objective, professional review and rebuttal services, identifying flaws in methodology, unsupported assumptions, and overreaching conclusions.
Our rebuttal reports are focused, well-reasoned, and respectful. We aim to help the trier of fact understand why the opposing expert’s conclusions may not hold up under scrutiny, and to support your case without unnecessary conflict.
What We Provide
Review of Opposing Expert Reports
- Line-by-line analysis of assumptions, methods, and conclusions
- Assessment of data sources, calculation logic, and industry alignment
- Identification of missing or misapplied evidence
Rebuttal Report Preparation
- Point-by-point response to key issues
- Independent recalculations where appropriate
- Clear language and graphics to explain divergence in findings
Rule 702 and Daubert/Frye Support
- Testing for reliability, transparency, and replicability
- Identification of speculative or subjective elements
- Assistance in preparing motions to exclude or limit expert testimony
Settlement Strategy & Trial Prep
- Input on strengths and weaknesses of opposing report
- Talking points and exhibits for deposition or trial
- Estimation of reasonable damages range for negotiation
Need an Expert to Review or Rebut an Opposing Report?
If you’re reviewing opposing testimony in a valuation or damages case, we can help you determine where the weaknesses lie, and how to respond with confidence and credibility.
Email or call Zach to discuss your case
zgilbert@royer-cpa.com | 207-956-6729
